Mixed Bag | Vintage & Collectibles in New York City

Free shipping on orders over $50 — Shop the thrift finds you'll love!

We proudly ship from the U.S.A.

Unearth Treasures, Embrace Value: Your Fun Thrift Adventure Awaits!

Thank you for visiting our thrift website! We truly appreciate your interest and want to assure you that every product photo is an actual image taken by us, so you can confidently see exactly what you'll receive. Enjoy exploring our unique selection and happy thrifting!

Whats New Bin

DC The Flash Batman + Batwing 27-inch Vehicle & Figure Target Exclusive New

DC The Flash Batman + Batwing 27-inch Vehicle & Figure Target Exclusive New

Regular price $44.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $44.99 USD
Parker Brothers Pay Day Board Game 1975 Vintage Family Strategy Game Good

Parker Brothers Pay Day Board Game 1975 Vintage Family Strategy Game Good

Regular price $24.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $24.99 USD
Tumasek Pewter Vase 97% Pewter Satin Finish Etched Detail Vintage Decor

Tumasek Pewter Vase 97% Pewter Satin Finish Etched Detail Vintage Decor

Regular price $28.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $28.99 USD
Vintage Silver Tone Scalloped Beaded Rim Decorative Bowl Trinket Dish Good

Vintage Silver Tone Scalloped Beaded Rim Decorative Bowl Trinket Dish Good

Regular price $54.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $54.99 USD
Handmade Talavera Shot Glasses Black White Floral Ceramic Set of 4 Vintage Style

Handmade Talavera Shot Glasses Black White Floral Ceramic Set of 4 Vintage Style

Regular price $69.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $69.99 USD
Mighty Jaxx Freeny's Hidden Dissectibles Cookie Monster Clear Blue Vinyl 4" Rare

Mighty Jaxx Freeny's Hidden Dissectibles Cookie Monster Clear Blue Vinyl 4" Rare

Regular price $54.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $54.99 USD
SARCASM Defense Against Stupidity T-Shirt XXL Military Green Funny Graphic Tee

SARCASM Defense Against Stupidity T-Shirt XXL Military Green Funny Graphic Tee

Regular price $14.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $14.99 USD
Sorry! Board Game 2005 – Hasbro Parker Brothers Family Sweet Revenge

Sorry! Board Game 2005 – Hasbro Parker Brothers Family Sweet Revenge

Regular price $19.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $19.99 USD
Hot Wheels 32 Ford Vicky Reyedclops Diecast Car 1:64 Scale Blue Vintage

Hot Wheels 32 Ford Vicky Reyedclops Diecast Car 1:64 Scale Blue Vintage

Regular price $12.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $12.99 USD
Alex My Doodle Pad 9x12 Newsprint Drawing Paper 100 Sheets 12 Pack New

Alex My Doodle Pad 9x12 Newsprint Drawing Paper 100 Sheets 12 Pack New

Regular price $44.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $44.99 USD

1 10

Movies Collection

HOPE Aliens Movie Alien Queen Digital Wrist Watch 3D Figure 1993 Vintage New

HOPE Aliens Movie Alien Queen Digital Wrist Watch 3D Figure 1993 Vintage New

Regular price $14.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $14.99 USD
Mercedes-Benz C-Class Secrets Harman Kardon Logic 7 Demo DVD 204 827 13 59 NEW

Mercedes-Benz C-Class Secrets Harman Kardon Logic 7 Demo DVD 204 827 13 59 NEW

Regular price $84.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $84.99 USD
SureSwatch 10002 Paintable Clear Film 9x12 3 Sheet Value Pack New Sealed

SureSwatch 10002 Paintable Clear Film 9x12 3 Sheet Value Pack New Sealed

Regular price $8.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $8.99 USD
Will Ferrell 7 Movie Comedy Night DVD Collection Anchorman Old School Used

Will Ferrell 7 Movie Comedy Night DVD Collection Anchorman Old School Used

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
Steve Carell 5-Movie Comedy DVD Collection 40 Year Old Virgin Get Smart Used

Steve Carell 5-Movie Comedy DVD Collection 40 Year Old Virgin Get Smart Used

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
Prince Purple Rain DVD 20th Anniversary 2-Disc Special Edition Used

Prince Purple Rain DVD 20th Anniversary 2-Disc Special Edition Used

Regular price $9.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.99 USD
MGM Eight Men Out DVD 2001 John Cusack Charlie Sheen Baseball Movie New Sealed

MGM Eight Men Out DVD 2001 John Cusack Charlie Sheen Baseball Movie New Sealed

Regular price $9.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.99 USD
New Line The New World DVD Colin Farrell Christian Bale Drama Good Tested

New Line The New World DVD Colin Farrell Christian Bale Drama Good Tested

Regular price $8.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $8.99 USD
Planet of the Apes DVD 2-Disc Special Edition Tim Burton Mark Wahlberg Good

Planet of the Apes DVD 2-Disc Special Edition Tim Burton Mark Wahlberg Good

Regular price $8.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $8.99 USD
Alien Resurrection DVD 1999 Sigourney Weaver Winona Ryder Sci-Fi Movie Used

Alien Resurrection DVD 1999 Sigourney Weaver Winona Ryder Sci-Fi Movie Used

Regular price $9.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.99 USD

1 10

Collectibles Collection

Gi-Go Toys Dino Re-Evolution Blue Dinosaur Vinyl Figure Toy Used

Gi-Go Toys Dino Re-Evolution Blue Dinosaur Vinyl Figure Toy Used

Regular price $4.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $4.99 USD
Baby Ghost of Kurosawa OG Edition Vinyl Figure Quiccs x Flabslab x Pobber Repair

Baby Ghost of Kurosawa OG Edition Vinyl Figure Quiccs x Flabslab x Pobber Repair

Regular price $199.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $199.99 USD
FiGPiN Lisa Simpson 761 The Simpsons Enamel Pin Collectible New Sealed

FiGPiN Lisa Simpson 761 The Simpsons Enamel Pin Collectible New Sealed

Regular price $9.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.99 USD
Vintage Elephant Figurine Doorstop Black Metal Animal Statue Decor

Vintage Elephant Figurine Doorstop Black Metal Animal Statue Decor

Regular price $16.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $16.99 USD
Vintage Ceramic Elephant Figurine Trunk Up Lucky Decor Grey Glazed Excellent

Vintage Ceramic Elephant Figurine Trunk Up Lucky Decor Grey Glazed Excellent

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
Elephant Figurine Trunk Up Good Luck Statue Black Home Decor Accent Vintage

Elephant Figurine Trunk Up Good Luck Statue Black Home Decor Accent Vintage

Regular price $17.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $17.99 USD
Vintage Japan Ceramic Elephant Figurine White Red Bow Trunk Up Good Luck Fair

Vintage Japan Ceramic Elephant Figurine White Red Bow Trunk Up Good Luck Fair

Regular price $19.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $19.99 USD
Vintage Japan Ceramic Elephant Figurine Trunk Up Good Luck Grey Brown Vintage

Vintage Japan Ceramic Elephant Figurine Trunk Up Good Luck Grey Brown Vintage

Regular price $16.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $16.99 USD
Unbranded Elephant Figurine Black Wood Carved Animal Sculpture Vintage Decor

Unbranded Elephant Figurine Black Wood Carved Animal Sculpture Vintage Decor

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
Pink Elephant Figurine Gold Accents Trunk Up Good Luck Decor Statue Vintage

Pink Elephant Figurine Gold Accents Trunk Up Good Luck Decor Statue Vintage

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD

1 10

...and so much more!

Browse below to discover a wide array of additional items waiting to be purchased.

Gifts Under $25

Parker Brothers Pay Day Board Game 1975 Vintage Family Strategy Game Good

Parker Brothers Pay Day Board Game 1975 Vintage Family Strategy Game Good

Regular price $24.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $24.99 USD
SARCASM Defense Against Stupidity T-Shirt XXL Military Green Funny Graphic Tee

SARCASM Defense Against Stupidity T-Shirt XXL Military Green Funny Graphic Tee

Regular price $14.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $14.99 USD
Sorry! Board Game 2005 – Hasbro Parker Brothers Family Sweet Revenge

Sorry! Board Game 2005 – Hasbro Parker Brothers Family Sweet Revenge

Regular price $19.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $19.99 USD
Hot Wheels 32 Ford Vicky Reyedclops Diecast Car 1:64 Scale Blue Vintage

Hot Wheels 32 Ford Vicky Reyedclops Diecast Car 1:64 Scale Blue Vintage

Regular price $12.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $12.99 USD
Silver Star in Wild Horse Canyon Basil Miller Vintage Hardcover Oliphants Ltd

Silver Star in Wild Horse Canyon Basil Miller Vintage Hardcover Oliphants Ltd

Regular price $14.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $14.99 USD
Gi-Go Toys Dino Re-Evolution Blue Dinosaur Vinyl Figure Toy Used

Gi-Go Toys Dino Re-Evolution Blue Dinosaur Vinyl Figure Toy Used

Regular price $4.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $4.99 USD
TOMY Pokémon Pikachu Electronic Talking Light-up Figure 1997 Vintage Toy

TOMY Pokémon Pikachu Electronic Talking Light-up Figure 1997 Vintage Toy

Regular price $4.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $4.99 USD
Hasbro Playskool Spider-Man 2011 5" Action Figure Marvel Super Hero Tested

Hasbro Playskool Spider-Man 2011 5" Action Figure Marvel Super Hero Tested

Regular price $8.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $8.99 USD
Apple iPhone 16 Pro Max 256GB Black Titanium Model Box Only

Apple iPhone 16 Pro Max 256GB Black Titanium Model Box Only

Regular price $14.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $14.99 USD
Timex Indiglo Women's Watch White Leather Strap Silver Tone Case Needs Battery

Timex Indiglo Women's Watch White Leather Strap Silver Tone Case Needs Battery

Regular price $19.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $19.99 USD
Female Vocal CD Lot Diana Krall Natalie Cole Sade Carole King Streisand

Female Vocal CD Lot Diana Krall Natalie Cole Sade Carole King Streisand

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
Spirooli Vegetable Slicer Spiralizer 3 Blades White As Seen On TV 2013 Open Box

Spirooli Vegetable Slicer Spiralizer 3 Blades White As Seen On TV 2013 Open Box

Regular price $14.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $14.99 USD
Empire Pewter Weighted Salt and Pepper Shakers Vintage Metal Tableware Pair Good

Empire Pewter Weighted Salt and Pepper Shakers Vintage Metal Tableware Pair Good

Regular price $24.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $24.99 USD
LEGO Creator 30584 Winter Holiday Train & 40512 VIP Funky Add On Set New Sealed

LEGO Creator 30584 Winter Holiday Train & 40512 VIP Funky Add On Set New Sealed

Regular price $19.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $19.99 USD
We Were There at the Oklahoma Land Run Jim Kjelgaard 1957 Grosset Dunlap

We Were There at the Oklahoma Land Run Jim Kjelgaard 1957 Grosset Dunlap

Regular price $19.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $19.99 USD
Pokemon TCG Sword & Shield Metal Damage Counter Dice Set of 6 Gold New

Pokemon TCG Sword & Shield Metal Damage Counter Dice Set of 6 Gold New

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
52TOYS Tom and Jerry WB 100th Anniversary Singin' in the Rain Figure New Box

52TOYS Tom and Jerry WB 100th Anniversary Singin' in the Rain Figure New Box

Regular price $19.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $19.99 USD
Beaumarchais Le Barbier de Seville Blackie's French Plays Vintage Book Fair

Beaumarchais Le Barbier de Seville Blackie's French Plays Vintage Book Fair

Regular price $19.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $19.99 USD
NFL New England Patriots Red Lanyard Keychain ID Holder Badge Reel

NFL New England Patriots Red Lanyard Keychain ID Holder Badge Reel

Regular price $11.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $11.99 USD
New York Rangers vs Philadelphia Flyers Ticket Stub - Dec 4, 1996 MSG NHL Game

New York Rangers vs Philadelphia Flyers Ticket Stub - Dec 4, 1996 MSG NHL Game

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
NHL New York Rangers vs Panthers Ticket Stub 10/29/1996 Gretzky Goal Vintage

NHL New York Rangers vs Panthers Ticket Stub 10/29/1996 Gretzky Goal Vintage

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
NHL New York Rangers vs Tampa Bay Lightning 1996 Ticket Stub MSG Vintage Vintage

NHL New York Rangers vs Tampa Bay Lightning 1996 Ticket Stub MSG Vintage Vintage

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
Men Are From Mars Board Game Mattel 1990s – Vintage Adult Party Game Used

Men Are From Mars Board Game Mattel 1990s – Vintage Adult Party Game Used

Regular price $19.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $19.99 USD
Dyce Hot Seat Card Game Adult Party Game Ages 10+ 3+ Players New Sealed

Dyce Hot Seat Card Game Adult Party Game Ages 10+ 3+ Players New Sealed

Regular price $13.49 USD

Regular price Sale price $13.49 USD

As seen on eBay

With a stellar reputation as seen on eBay, we pride ourselves on trustworthiness and customer satisfaction, making us the perfect choice for your next purchase.

Blog posts

A Collector's Guide to Vintage Board Games and ...

August 11, 2026
A guide to collecting vintage board games and trading cards — from checking completeness and box condition to grading and spotting fake cards.

A Collector's Guide to Vintage Board Games and ...

August 11, 2026
A guide to collecting vintage board games and trading cards — from checking completeness and box condition to grading and spotting fake cards.
What to Look for When Buying Used DVDs and Blu-...

August 11, 2026
A practical guide to buying used DVDs and Blu-rays — how to inspect discs, spot disc rot, and find out-of-print titles worth collecting.

What to Look for When Buying Used DVDs and Blu-...

August 11, 2026
A practical guide to buying used DVDs and Blu-rays — how to inspect discs, spot disc rot, and find out-of-print titles worth collecting.
How to Identify Authentic Vintage Collectibles ...

August 11, 2026
Learn how to spot authentic vintage collectibles and memorabilia — from examining materials and markings to evaluating autographs and wear patterns.

How to Identify Authentic Vintage Collectibles ...

August 11, 2026
Learn how to spot authentic vintage collectibles and memorabilia — from examining materials and markings to evaluating autographs and wear patterns.

1 3