Mixed Bag | Vintage & Collectibles in New York City

Free shipping on orders over $50 — Shop the thrift finds you'll love!

We proudly ship from the U.S.A.

Unearth Treasures, Embrace Value: Your Fun Thrift Adventure Awaits!

Thank you for visiting our thrift website! We truly appreciate your interest and want to assure you that every product photo is an actual image taken by us, so you can confidently see exactly what you'll receive. Enjoy exploring our unique selection and happy thrifting!

Whats New Bin

Florida Panthers vs. New York Rangers Ticket Stub October 29, 1996 Gretzky Goal

Florida Panthers vs. New York Rangers Ticket Stub October 29, 1996 Gretzky Goal

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
Scrabble Board Game, Classic Word Game For Kids Ages 8 & Up Fun Family Game New

Scrabble Board Game, Classic Word Game For Kids Ages 8 & Up Fun Family Game New

Regular price $19.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $19.99 USD
New York Rangers vs Philadelphia Flyers Ticket Stub - Dec 4, 1996 MSG NHL Game

New York Rangers vs Philadelphia Flyers Ticket Stub - Dec 4, 1996 MSG NHL Game

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
New York Rangers vs Tampa Bay Lightning April 12, 1996 Ticket Stub - MSG

New York Rangers vs Tampa Bay Lightning April 12, 1996 Ticket Stub - MSG

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
Men Are From Mars Board Game Mattel 1990s – Vintage Adult Party Game Used

Men Are From Mars Board Game Mattel 1990s – Vintage Adult Party Game Used

Regular price $19.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $19.99 USD
Monopoly 40th Anniversary Edition Board Game Vintage 1974 Parker Brothers

Monopoly 40th Anniversary Edition Board Game Vintage 1974 Parker Brothers

Regular price $29.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $29.99 USD
eLephas W13 LED Projector Keystone Focus USB HDMI VGA AV Ports Black

eLephas W13 LED Projector Keystone Focus USB HDMI VGA AV Ports Black

Regular price $39.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $39.99 USD
Dyce Hot Seat Card Game Adult Party Game New Sealed

Dyce Hot Seat Card Game Adult Party Game New Sealed

Regular price $13.49 USD

Regular price Sale price $13.49 USD
2004 Hot Wheels First Editions MITSUBISHI ECLIPSE #090 Loose Convertible

2004 Hot Wheels First Editions MITSUBISHI ECLIPSE #090 Loose Convertible

Regular price $9.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.99 USD
Russell Athletic Washington Redskins #80 Jersey Size 52 Vintage NFL Burgundy

Russell Athletic Washington Redskins #80 Jersey Size 52 Vintage NFL Burgundy

Regular price $89.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $89.99 USD

1 10

Movies Collection

Aliens Movie Digital Wrist Watch - 3D Alien Queen Figure, Moveable Head & Tail

Aliens Movie Digital Wrist Watch - 3D Alien Queen Figure, Moveable Head & Tail

Regular price $14.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $14.99 USD
Mercedes-Benz C-Class Secrets Harman Kardon Logic 7 Demo DVD 204 827 13 59 NEW

Mercedes-Benz C-Class Secrets Harman Kardon Logic 7 Demo DVD 204 827 13 59 NEW

Regular price $84.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $84.99 USD
SureSwatch 10002 Paintable Clear Film 9x12 3 Sheet Value Pack New Sealed

SureSwatch 10002 Paintable Clear Film 9x12 3 Sheet Value Pack New Sealed

Regular price $8.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $8.99 USD
Will Ferrell Seven Movie Comedy Night DVD Collection (Used)

Will Ferrell Seven Movie Comedy Night DVD Collection (Used)

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
Steve Carell Five-Movie Comedy Night DVD Collection (Used)

Steve Carell Five-Movie Comedy Night DVD Collection (Used)

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
Eight Men Out - (DVD, 2001)

Eight Men Out - (DVD, 2001)

Regular price $9.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.99 USD
PURPLE RAIN - Prince - 2 Disc 20th Anniversary Edition DVD

PURPLE RAIN - Prince - 2 Disc 20th Anniversary Edition DVD

Regular price $9.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.99 USD
New Line The New World DVD Colin Farrell Christian Bale Historical Drama Good

New Line The New World DVD Colin Farrell Christian Bale Historical Drama Good

Regular price $8.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $8.99 USD
Planet of the Apes DVD 2-Disc Special Edition Tim Burton Mark Wahlberg Good

Planet of the Apes DVD 2-Disc Special Edition Tim Burton Mark Wahlberg Good

Regular price $8.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $8.99 USD
Alien Resurrection DVD 1999 Sigourney Weaver Winona Ryder Joss Whedon

Alien Resurrection DVD 1999 Sigourney Weaver Winona Ryder Joss Whedon

Regular price $9.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.99 USD

1 10

Collectibles Collection

Baby Ghost of Kurosawa OG Edition Vinyl Figure Quiccs x Flabslab x Pobber Repair

Baby Ghost of Kurosawa OG Edition Vinyl Figure Quiccs x Flabslab x Pobber Repair

Regular price $199.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $199.99 USD
FiGPiN Lisa Simpson 761 The Simpsons Enamel Pin Collectible New Sealed

FiGPiN Lisa Simpson 761 The Simpsons Enamel Pin Collectible New Sealed

Regular price $9.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.99 USD
Black Elephant Statue Figurine Home Decor Accent Tabletop Vintage Display

Black Elephant Statue Figurine Home Decor Accent Tabletop Vintage Display

Regular price $16.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $16.99 USD
Elephant Coin Bank Ceramic Figurine Animal Decor Nursery Decor Pastel

Elephant Coin Bank Ceramic Figurine Animal Decor Nursery Decor Pastel

Regular price $29.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $29.99 USD
Elephant Figurine Ceramic Animal Statue Decor Gray Home Vintage Accent

Elephant Figurine Ceramic Animal Statue Decor Gray Home Vintage Accent

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
Elephant Statue Figurine Trunk Up Decor Good Luck Charm Home Accent Black

Elephant Statue Figurine Trunk Up Decor Good Luck Charm Home Accent Black

Regular price $17.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $17.99 USD
Vintage Ceramic Elephant Figurine Red Bow Cute Animal Decor Vintage Collectible

Vintage Ceramic Elephant Figurine Red Bow Cute Animal Decor Vintage Collectible

Regular price $19.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $19.99 USD
Elephant Figurine Statue Decor Black Wood Carved Animal Sculpture

Elephant Figurine Statue Decor Black Wood Carved Animal Sculpture

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
Elephant Figurine Ceramic Animal Statue Decor Home Accent Vintage Style

Elephant Figurine Ceramic Animal Statue Decor Home Accent Vintage Style

Regular price $15.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $15.99 USD
Pink Elephant Figurine Gold Accents Trunk Up Good Luck Decor Statue

Pink Elephant Figurine Gold Accents Trunk Up Good Luck Decor Statue

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD

1 10

...and so much more!

Browse below to discover a wide array of additional items waiting to be purchased.

Gifts Under $25

McFarlane Toys Epic Games FORTNITE SKULL TROOPER Action Figure 2018

McFarlane Toys Epic Games FORTNITE SKULL TROOPER Action Figure 2018

Regular price $14.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $14.99 USD
Florida Panthers vs. New York Rangers Ticket Stub October 29, 1996 Gretzky Goal

Florida Panthers vs. New York Rangers Ticket Stub October 29, 1996 Gretzky Goal

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
New York Rangers vs Philadelphia Flyers Ticket Stub - Dec 4, 1996 MSG NHL Game

New York Rangers vs Philadelphia Flyers Ticket Stub - Dec 4, 1996 MSG NHL Game

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
Scrabble Board Game, Classic Word Game For Kids Ages 8 & Up Fun Family Game New

Scrabble Board Game, Classic Word Game For Kids Ages 8 & Up Fun Family Game New

Regular price $19.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $19.99 USD
New York Rangers vs Tampa Bay Lightning April 12, 1996 Ticket Stub - MSG

New York Rangers vs Tampa Bay Lightning April 12, 1996 Ticket Stub - MSG

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
Men Are From Mars Board Game Mattel 1990s – Vintage Adult Party Game Used

Men Are From Mars Board Game Mattel 1990s – Vintage Adult Party Game Used

Regular price $19.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $19.99 USD
Dyce Hot Seat Card Game Adult Party Game New Sealed

Dyce Hot Seat Card Game Adult Party Game New Sealed

Regular price $13.49 USD

Regular price Sale price $13.49 USD
2004 Hot Wheels First Editions MITSUBISHI ECLIPSE #090 Loose Convertible

2004 Hot Wheels First Editions MITSUBISHI ECLIPSE #090 Loose Convertible

Regular price $9.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.99 USD
Hot Wheels 67 Pontiac GTO Richard Petty 43 Wheaties Salute to Petty Blue Used

Hot Wheels 67 Pontiac GTO Richard Petty 43 Wheaties Salute to Petty Blue Used

Regular price $8.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $8.99 USD
Rae Dunn Happy Holidays Bottle Gift Bags Set of 3 Wine Liquor Bags New

Rae Dunn Happy Holidays Bottle Gift Bags Set of 3 Wine Liquor Bags New

Regular price $19.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $19.99 USD
J. Racine Athalie French Tragedy Book 1898 Hachette French Classics Vintage

J. Racine Athalie French Tragedy Book 1898 Hachette French Classics Vintage

Regular price $14.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $14.99 USD
Aliens Movie Digital Wrist Watch - 3D Alien Queen Figure, Moveable Head & Tail

Aliens Movie Digital Wrist Watch - 3D Alien Queen Figure, Moveable Head & Tail

Regular price $14.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $14.99 USD
Hot Wheels - 1957 Chevy Bel Air - Made Malaysia 1976 - Metallic Blue

Hot Wheels - 1957 Chevy Bel Air - Made Malaysia 1976 - Metallic Blue

Regular price $6.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $6.99 USD
Welly 1970 Ford Mustang Yellow 1:64 Scale Vehicle #2223 Loose

Welly 1970 Ford Mustang Yellow 1:64 Scale Vehicle #2223 Loose

Regular price $9.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.99 USD
Hot Wheels 1982 Camaro Z-28 Neon Orange w/ Chrome Wheels – 1:64 Loose Car

Hot Wheels 1982 Camaro Z-28 Neon Orange w/ Chrome Wheels – 1:64 Loose Car

Regular price $9.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.99 USD
Majorette 1986-1993 Cadillac Allante Roadster Bright Green Allanté #253 1:59

Majorette 1986-1993 Cadillac Allante Roadster Bright Green Allanté #253 1:59

Regular price $14.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $14.99 USD
Vintage Style Decorative World Globe Wood Base Higgins India Ink Graphic 8in

Vintage Style Decorative World Globe Wood Base Higgins India Ink Graphic 8in

Regular price $24.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $24.99 USD
The Adventures of Buffalo Bill Col William F Cody Bonanza Book Hardcover Western

The Adventures of Buffalo Bill Col William F Cody Bonanza Book Hardcover Western

Regular price $21.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $21.99 USD
Grade Saver Pro 100 Count Card Sleeves Standard Size 35pt Ultra Clear

Grade Saver Pro 100 Count Card Sleeves Standard Size 35pt Ultra Clear

Regular price $5.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $5.00 USD
Lenox Federal Platinum Nouveau Square Dinner Plate Fine Bone China

Lenox Federal Platinum Nouveau Square Dinner Plate Fine Bone China

Regular price $14.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $14.99 USD
Vintage 1987 Antioch Reflections Bookmarks Jill Wolf Why God Made Families 2pc

Vintage 1987 Antioch Reflections Bookmarks Jill Wolf Why God Made Families 2pc

Regular price $9.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.99 USD
Pokemon Center Charizard Gigantamax Card Sleeves 130ct TCG Standard Size 2022

Pokemon Center Charizard Gigantamax Card Sleeves 130ct TCG Standard Size 2022

Regular price $18.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.99 USD
Handless Inc Black Faux Leather Wide Leg Pants High Waisted Seam Detail Size L

Handless Inc Black Faux Leather Wide Leg Pants High Waisted Seam Detail Size L

Regular price $24.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $24.99 USD
Microsoft Xbox 360 Kinect Sensor Motion Camera Bar Black Tested

Microsoft Xbox 360 Kinect Sensor Motion Camera Bar Black Tested

Regular price $14.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $14.99 USD

As seen on eBay

With a stellar reputation as seen on eBay, we pride ourselves on trustworthiness and customer satisfaction, making us the perfect choice for your next purchase.

Blog posts

A Collector's Guide to Vintage Board Games and ...

August 11, 2026
A guide to collecting vintage board games and trading cards — from checking completeness and box condition to grading and spotting fake cards.

A Collector's Guide to Vintage Board Games and ...

August 11, 2026
A guide to collecting vintage board games and trading cards — from checking completeness and box condition to grading and spotting fake cards.
What to Look for When Buying Used DVDs and Blu-...

August 11, 2026
A practical guide to buying used DVDs and Blu-rays — how to inspect discs, spot disc rot, and find out-of-print titles worth collecting.

What to Look for When Buying Used DVDs and Blu-...

August 11, 2026
A practical guide to buying used DVDs and Blu-rays — how to inspect discs, spot disc rot, and find out-of-print titles worth collecting.
How to Identify Authentic Vintage Collectibles ...

August 11, 2026
Learn how to spot authentic vintage collectibles and memorabilia — from examining materials and markings to evaluating autographs and wear patterns.

How to Identify Authentic Vintage Collectibles ...

August 11, 2026
Learn how to spot authentic vintage collectibles and memorabilia — from examining materials and markings to evaluating autographs and wear patterns.

1 3